


Shortcuts 



•••
Related
links
Puzzles
workshops for
schools & museums.
Editorial
content and syndication puzzles for the media,
editors & publishers.
AbracadaBrain Teasers
and Puzzles!
Numbers,
just numbers...
Have
a Math question?
Ask Dr.
Math!

•••

•••
Logic
smile!
If
you want to build a ship
don't herd people together to collect wood
and don't assign them tasks and work,
but rather teach them to long for the
endless immensity of the sea...
 A. SaintExupery
Original
text:
Si tu veux construire un bateau,
ne rassemble pas des hommes pour aller chercher du bois,
préparer des outils,
répartir les taches,
alléger le travail,
mais enseigne aux gens la nostalgie de l’infini de la mer...
 A.
SaintExupery

•••
SPACE
INVADERS
Play
Space Invaders online!



Previous
Puzzles of the Month + Solutions


SeptemberOctober
2008, Puzzle nr 119 
Back to PuzzleoftheMonth
page  Home 
Puzzle
# 119 Difficulty
level: ,
general math knowledge.
Perpendicular
or not?
The
large circle (O_{1}, B)
above circumscribes 2 smaller circles (with centers O_{2} and O_{3},
respectively) and an isosceles triangle, whose base stands on the diameter of
the large circle. As shown in the drawing, each geometric shape touches the 3
other ones. Points A, O_{1}, O_{2} and B are
aligned. Demonstrate that the segment O_{3}A is
perpendicular to the diameter AB.
Keywords:
incircles, isosceles, perpendicular, secanttangent.
Related
puzzles:
 Ratio of
similar triangles.
 Soccer
ball problem.
 Ad
angolo retto?
Il grande cerchio (O_{1}, B)
circoscrive 2 cerchi minori (con i rispettivi centri O_{2} e O_{3})
e un triangolo isoscele, la cui base si confonde
col diametro del grande cerchio. Ogni figura geometrica
tocca ognuna delle altre tre. I punti A, O_{1}, O_{2} e B sono
allineati. Dimostrare che il segmento O_{3}A è perpendicolare
al diametro AB.
Parole
chiave: cerchio inscritto, isoscelo, perpendicolare.
Suggerisci un'altra
soluzione Chiudi
 A
angle droit?
Le grand cercle (O_{1}, B)
circonscrit 2 autres cercles plus petits (ayant
pour centres O_{2} et O_{3},
respectivement) ainsi qu’un triangle isocèle,
dont la base se trouve sur le diamètre du
grand cercle. Chaque figure géométrique
touche les 3 autres. Les points A, O_{1}, O_{2} et B sont
alignés. Démontrer que le segment O_{3}A est
bien perpendiculaire au diamètre AB.
Mots
clés: cercle inscrit, isocèle,
perpendiculaire.
Propose une
autre solution Fermer

Source
of the puzzle:
Sangaku tablet of Gunma prefecture (群馬県; Gunmaken),
1803. ©G. Sarcone. 


Some
interesting considerations
• In fig. 1, we can see that triangles A'BC' and ABC are
similar.
• In fig. 2, we can see that AC' and AE' are tangent
to the circle with center O_{3}. The segment O_{3}A represents
then the symmetry axis along which the right triangle AO_{3}D is
reflected on AE'.
What we have to prove
If we prove that angle γ (gamma,
see fig. 2) of the right triangle AO_{3}D is complementary to
angle α (alpha) of the isosceles
triangle AC'A', then we prove that points E and E' are
identical, and consecutively the segment O_{3}A is
perpendicular to the diameter AB.
a)
It is given:
radius O_{1}B = R (see
fig. 3)
radius O_{2}B = r
radius O_{3}D = p
segment O_{3}A = t
β = 90°  α
b)
According to the drawing:
A’C’ = AC’
MA = MA' = R  r
h ⊥ AA'
p ⊥ AC’
O_{1}O_{3} = R  p
O_{1}A = 2r  R
O_{1}M = O_{2}B = r
O_{2}O_{3} = r + p
c)
According to the 'SecantTangent' theorem (see
further below):
t^{2} = p(p +
2r)
d)
According to the Pythagorean theorem:
t^{2} + O_{1}A^{2} = O_{1}O_{3}^{2 } →
t^{2} + (2r  R)^{2} =
(R  p)^{2}
e)
Solving the equations in c) and d)
together, we obtain:
t = 2r[2R(R  r)]
/ (R + r)
and
p = 2r(R  r)
/ (R + r)
f)
According to the Pythagorean theorem:
1) h = (O_{1}C'^{2}  O_{1}M^{2})
= (O_{1}B^{2}  O_{1}M^{2})
= (R^{2}  r^{2})
and
2) AC’^{2} = h^{2} + MA^{2} =
(R^{2}  r^{2})
+ (R  r)^{2} →
AC’ = [2R(R + r)]
g)
By solving the following equations:
1) (p / t)^{2} = p^{2 }/ t^{2} =
[2r(R  r)]^{2}/ 4r^{2}[2R(R  r)]
=
= [2r(R  r)]^{2} / 4rR[2r(R  r)]
= (R  r) / 2R
and
2)
(MA / AC')^{2} = MA^{2} / AC'^{2} =
(R  r)^{2} / 2R(R + r)
= (R  r) / 2R
We proved that p / t = MA / AC',
then the triangles AO_{3}D and AC'M are
similar, hence angle DÂO_{3 }=
angle β = 90°  α.
In conclusion, angle γ (or DÂO_{3})
being complementary to
angle α, the segment O_{3}A is
perpendicular to the diameter AB.
(You
will find here a
more geometric way to solve this puzzle)
The
Winners of the Puzzle of the Month are:
No winners... Yes, the puzzle was
a little bit harder.
Sorry!

© 2005 G.
Sarcone, www.archimedeslab.org
You can reuse content from Archimedes’ Lab
on the ONLY condition that you provide credit to the
authors (© G.
Sarcone and/or M.J.
Waeber) and a link back to our site. You CANNOT
reproduce the content of this page for commercial
purposes.

You're
encouraged to expand and/or improve this article. Send
your comments, feedback or suggestions to Gianni
A. Sarcone. Thanks! 

More
Math Facts behind the puzzle
Secanttangent
theorem: fig. 1) c^{2} = a(a + b) and
fig. 2) c^{2} = a(a +
2r)
The
angle, formed between a tangent line and a chord,
is congruent to the inscribed angle on the other
side of the chord and subtended by the chord (angle α' =
angle α, see fig. 3). Then, with similar
triangles:
c / (a + b) = a / c


Previous
puzzles of the month...




Back to PuzzleoftheMonth
page  Home
Recommend
this page 

